I Beg Your Pardon part 5
PRETEND
29:23Apr 14, 2026
PRETEND
305 episodes
Listen to all of these podcast episodes and more with the StumbleCast app. StumbleCast works like a radio — pick a genre and start listening instantly. Swipe to discover new podcasts and internet radio stations. Every episode starts at a random point, just like changing the channel.
I Beg Your Pardon part 4
PRETEND
25:50Apr 7, 2026
Introducing Season Seven of Nobody Should Believe Me
PRETEND
1:04:10Mar 31, 2026
I Beg Your Pardon part 3
PRETEND
36:03Mar 24, 2026
I Beg Your Pardon part 2
PRETEND
40:39Mar 17, 2026
I Beg Your Pardon part 1
PRETEND
38:30Mar 10, 2026
Who's Afraid of LaDonna Humphrey Revisited
PRETEND
42:40Mar 3, 2026
Update on “The Hand That Held Me”
PRETEND
0:48Feb 28, 2026
The Pests part 3 & 4 Revisited
PRETEND
1:21:14Feb 24, 2026
The Pests part 1 & 2 Revisited
PRETEND
1:03:35Feb 17, 2026
2505: State of Corruption: The School That Didn't Exist
PRETEND
39:37Feb 10, 2026
Introducing Everything They Missed
PRETEND
34:47Feb 6, 2026
2504: How to Spot a Fake ICE Agent
PRETEND
33:09Feb 3, 2026
Listener Reaction: Didn't See It Coming Part 3
PRETEND
16:46Jan 31, 2026
2503: Didn't See It Coming (Part 3)
PRETEND
43:26Jan 27, 2026
Listener Reaction: Didn't See It Coming part 2
PRETEND
25:18Jan 24, 2026
2502: Didn't See It Coming (Part 2)
PRETEND
33:01Jan 20, 2026
Listener Reaction: Didn't See That Coming Part 1
PRETEND
26:52Jan 17, 2026
2501: Didn't See It Coming (Part 1)
PRETEND
39:28Jan 13, 2026
2408: PRETEND Live AMA
PRETEND
1:06:09Jan 6, 2026
2407-Licensed to Kill Revisited
PRETEND
1:16:51Dec 30, 2025
2406: The Real Life Grinch
PRETEND
37:12Dec 23, 2025
Listener Reaction: Matthew Fenner vs. Ted Bell (Bonus)
PRETEND
29:42Dec 20, 2025
2405: The Prophet: Matthew Fenner vs Ted Bell
PRETEND
58:41Dec 17, 2025
Off Script: Pretend, Murder She Told & Sins and Survivors Spill the Tea (BONUS)
PRETEND
36:42Dec 16, 2025
2404: Open Enrollment, Open Season for Scammers
PRETEND
28:00Dec 9, 2025
2403: The Cancer Sympathy Machine part 3
PRETEND
41:32Dec 2, 2025
Listener Reaction: The Cancer Sympathy Machine
PRETEND
20:22Nov 28, 2025
2402: The Cancer Sympathy Machine part 2
PRETEND
30:34Nov 25, 2025
2401: The Cancer Sympathy Machine part 1
PRETEND
37:49Nov 18, 2025
Dakota Spotlight: Meanwhile in Mankato
PRETEND
56:03Nov 17, 2025
2309: From Smallville to NXIVM: The Psychology Behind Allison Mack
PRETEND
43:23Nov 11, 2025
Bonus: The Psychology Behind Parasocial Relationships (Cracks in the Fandom)
PRETEND
28:05Nov 10, 2025
The Hypnotist - Alien Abductions
PRETEND
39:56Nov 1, 2025
The Haunted Tourist
PRETEND
1:00:29Oct 31, 2025
The Real Vampires
PRETEND
43:00Oct 30, 2025
2304: Cracks in the Fandom part 4
PRETEND
56:21Oct 28, 2025
2303: Cracks in the Fandom part 3
PRETEND
44:53Oct 21, 2025
2302: Cracks in the Fandom part 2
PRETEND
41:55Oct 14, 2025
2301: Cracks in the Fandom part 1
PRETEND
39:13Oct 6, 2025
2210: The High School Hoax Update
PRETEND
32:37Sep 30, 2025
2209: The Stalker: Rick Fernandez’s Guilty Plea
PRETEND
12:25Sep 23, 2025
2208: The Monster
PRETEND
43:58Sep 16, 2025
2208: State of Corruption: Ohio part 2
PRETEND
40:37Sep 9, 2025
2207: State of Corruption: Ohio part 1
PRETEND
36:45Sep 2, 2025
The Real Donnie Brasco - FBI Case File Review
PRETEND
1:11:40Aug 28, 2025
2205: Who’s Afraid of LaDonna Humphrey Part 18: The 911 Caller
PRETEND
55:28Aug 19, 2025
2204: Who's Afraid of LaDonna Humphrey part 17
PRETEND
30:08Aug 12, 2025
"Nobody Should Believe Me" — When the Advocate Is the Abuser
PRETEND
52:45Aug 5, 2025
2203: The Playwright part 3
PRETEND
43:52Jul 29, 2025